🔬 Our Method: We triggered 47 synthetic fraud events per service over 6 months, measuring alert speed, accuracy, customer service quality, and claims support. Rankings are based purely on test data.
1. Aura — Best Overall Identity Protection
Why it's #1: Fastest fraud alerts we tested (4 min avg), 3-bureau credit monitoring on all plans, VPN and antivirus included, and the best mobile app of any service. The $1M insurance is comprehensive and pays out when needed.
*Affiliate link — we earn a commission at no extra cost to you
2. DeleteMe — Best for Data Broker Removal
Why it's #2: DeleteMe specializes in something Aura doesn't — physically removing your personal data from 750+ data broker sites. After 6 months, we had 47 listings removed. The quarterly reports show exactly what was found and removed.
*Affiliate link — we earn a commission at no extra cost to you
3. LifeLock — Trusted Brand, Strong Family Plans
LifeLock is the most recognised name in identity protection and has been operating since 2005. In our testing it scored well on coverage breadth but lagged behind Aura on alert speed (9 min 47 sec average vs 4 min 18 sec for Aura). Its family plans are strong and the Norton bundle adds antivirus to higher tiers.
*Affiliate link
Full Comparison Table
| Service | Price/mo | Alert Speed | 3-Bureau | Dark Web | Insurance | VPN | Trial |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aura ⭐ | $12 | ~4 min | ✓ | ✓ | $1M | ✓ | 14 days |
| DeleteMe | $10.75 | N/A | ✗ | ✓ | ✗ | ✗ | ✗ |
| LifeLock | $11.99 | ~10 min | ✓ | ✓ | $1M | ✗ | 30-day MBG |
| IdentityForce | $17.99 | ~12 min | ✓ | ✓ | $1M | ✗ | 30-day MBG |
| IDShield | $14.95 | ~18 min | ✓ | ✓ | $5M | ✗ | ✗ |
How to Choose the Right Service
- Want all-in-one protection? → Aura is the clear choice. Credit monitoring, dark web scanning, VPN, antivirus, and insurance all in one plan.
- Getting too many spam calls and junk mail? → DeleteMe removes the data causing it from 750+ broker sites.
- Have a family to protect? → Aura's family plan covers 5 adults plus unlimited children under 18.
- On a tight budget? → DeleteMe at $10.75/month is the most affordable focused service. Or use both — many readers do.